After snapping a six-year playoff streak last season, the New York Yankees made a bold trade for slugger Juan Soto this offseason.
But the momentum created by that deal all but evaporated once ace pitcher Gerrit Cole, the reigning AL Cy Young winner, was lost to a worrisome arm injury since identified as nerve inflammation and edema. The Yankees, who sacrificed plenty of pitching depth in the Soto deal, aren’t built to withstand the loss of Cole.
Few (if any) teams are.
Yet, the Yankees aren’t hopeless. They just find themselves in significant need of a significant upgrade, and it just so happens that the free agent market still has one available.
Jordan Montgomery, who opened his MLB career in pinstripes, remains unsigned after pitching to a 3.20 ERA last season and getting even stingier (2.90 ERA across 31 innings) come playoff time while helping steer the Texas Rangers to their first World Series title.
Montgomery’s camp had spoken with New York earlier in the offseason, and Jon Heyman of the New York Post reported “they are back in contact.”
It’s time to get a deal done. The Yankees’ hopes for this season could easily depend on it.
New York’s Rotation Needs a Jolt
New York Yankees/Getty Images
MLB.com’s Anthony Castrovince recently ranked the league’s top 10 rotations. Actually, the scribe went even a little further than that, since his 10th spot featured a three-way tie between the Baltimore Orioles, Houston Astros and Miami Marlins.
The Yankees, as you may have surmised already, were excluded from that list.
And while they at least cracked the honorable mention section, their inclusion came with several caveats: “If and only if Gerrit Cole comes back quickly and Nestor Cortes and Carlos Rodón both bounce back, the Yankees belong.”
That’s hardly a ringing endorsement of this rotation, and who knows how many (if any) of those caveats will even come true. Yet, that’s the state of this pitching staff, which will feature Cortes, who posted a 4.97 ERA across 63.1 innings last season, on the bump for Opening Day.
An Investment in Montgomery Feels Safe
Daniel Shirey/MLB Photos via Getty Images
Safety is, of course, a relative term when it comes to starting pitchers, given the position’s laundry list of injury issues and general unpredictability.
As far as starting pitchers go, though, Montgomery certainly lands on the safer side. He has cleared 155 innings while posting an ERA of 3.83 or better in each of the past three seasons.
He’s been even sharper over the past two. In 2022, he set a career-high with 178.1 innings and a career-low 3.48 ERA. Then, he bettered both marks this past season (188.2 innings and a 3.20 ERA) before seeing even better results in the playoffs.
If the Yankees sign Montgomery, they can reasonably expect reliability. And given all of the question marks with this staff, that’s something they desperately need.
Montgomery’s Cost Shouldn’t Be Astronomic
![](https://media.bleacherreport.com/image/upload/w_800,h_533,c_fill/v1711077031/qdj3qnejmpstfehnsqg8.jpg)
Cooper Neill/MLB Photos via Getty Images
Given the way he pitched last season, and the way he elevated that performance on baseball’s biggest stage, Montgomery surely once held designs of striking it rich this offseason.
Heyman reported that Montgomery’s camp compared him to Aaron Hola, who got a seven-year, $172 million deal from the Philadelphia Phillies. At that price, the Yankees were probably out, especially since they’d be luxury-taxed on every dollar spent.
But Montgomery could be learning what so many other clients of his agent, Scott Boras, have discovered: Most teams aren’t interested in handing out blank checks. That’s why Cody Bellinger, Matt Chapman and Blake Snell all wound up settling for short-term pacts with opt-outs offering them chances to re-enter free agency as soon as next offseason. Slugger J.D. Martinez couldn’t even find that much, despite tallying 33 homers and 103 RBI in just 113 games last season, and wound up with a one-year, $12 million deal with the New York Mets.
It’s impossible to know what kind of contract Montgomery would accept, but it’s probably safe to assume it won’t be as lucrative as whatever had first had in mind. So long as the pay rate is reasonable, the Yankees should pounce, especially since he couldn’t sign a qualifying offer and therefore wouldn’t include any additional costs, like draft picks or international pool money.
News
Yankees’ Gerrit Cole gets murky injury update from Aaron Boone
Yankees manager Aaron Boone provides the latest Gerrit Cole update. New York Yankees ace Gerrit Cole is eligible to return from the injured list in late May. Yankees manager Aaron Boone recently…
New York Yankees’ Star Slugger Returns as Team Looks to Split Series With Orioles
The New York Yankees are getting a major boost to their lineup for their series finale with the Baltimore Orioles as they look to split a four-game…
Nike agrees to save Carlos Rodón, make much-needed change to broken Yankees jerseys
Someone, somewhere needs to unplug the new Yankees’ Super Wet road jerseys and plug them back in. Luckily, after months of MLB’s silence, it appears Nike will…
Yankees could have another trade steal in this surging right-hander
Feb 29, 2024; Tampa, Florida, USA; New York Yankees starting pitcher Clayton Beeter (85) throws a pitch during the first inning against the Miami Marlins at George…
Yankees reinstate outfielder from paternity list, offense gets a jolt
Alex Verdugo was not available for the first three games of this series for the Yankees as he was placed on the paternity list prior to the series kicking off….
Yankees News: Clay Holmes destroys Orioles, Luis Gil rebound, Aaron Judge slide
Scary Clay Holmes is here. May 1, 2024; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; New York Yankees pitcher Clay Holmes (35) throws a eighth / Tommy Gilligan-USA TODAY Sports On…
End of content
No more pages to load